Rhoda - Season One DVD Review - Sitcoms Online Message Boards

TJ · 03-19-2009, 01:51 AM

“My name is Rhoda Morgenstern. I was born in the Bronx, New York in December 1941.” That was how Valerie Harper began every single episode of the first season of Rhoda, the first spinoff of the popular 1970s TV series, The Mary Tyler Moore Show. And now, that very first season of Rhoda is available on DVD, for the very first time! Season One contains all 24 episodes of the 1974-1975 season of the series on a four disc DVD set, just in time for the 35th anniversary.

Rhoda Morgenstern began as a character on The Mary Tyler Moore Show, but proved to be popular enough to earn her own sitcom by 1974. The series begins as she takes a vacation back home to New York and stays with her sister, Brenda (Julie Kavner). While staying with her sister, she meets a construction worker named Joe (David Groh) and they hit it off almost immediately. Things go so well that Rhoda decides to stay in Manhattan for a while, but as she emphasizes in her opening monologue, “New York, this is your last chance!” The series ran for five seasons on CBS and Rhoda and Joe eventually married each other... and then eventually divorced each other... but the series went on anyway. The show also stars Nancy Walker as Rhoda’s overbearing mother, Ida, and Harold Gould as her more understand father, Martin.

Read our review by Skees here:
http://www.sitcomsonline.com/rhodaseason1dvdreview.html

Please post any questions or comments about this set.

TeeVeeCloset · 03-19-2009, 11:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TJ

“My name is Rhoda Morgenstern. I was born in the Bronx, New York in December 1941.” That was how Valerie Harper began every single episode of the first season of Rhoda, the first spinoff of the popular 1970s TV series, The Mary Tyler Moore Show. And now, that very first season of Rhoda is available on DVD, for the very first time! Season One contains all 24 episodes of the 1974-1975 season of the series on a four disc DVD set, just in time for the 35th anniversary.

Rhoda Morgenstern began as a character on The Mary Tyler Moore Show, but proved to be popular enough to earn her own sitcom by 1974. The series begins as she takes a vacation back home to New York and stays with her sister, Brenda (Julie Kavner). While staying with her sister, she meets a construction worker named Joe (David Groh) and they hit it off almost immediately. Things go so well that Rhoda decides to stay in Manhattan for a while, but as she emphasizes in her opening monologue, “New York, this is your last chance!” The series ran for five seasons on CBS and Rhoda and Joe eventually married each other... and then eventually divorced each other... but the series went on anyway. The show also stars Nancy Martin as Rhoda’s overbearing mother, Ida, and Harold Gould as her more understand father, Martin.

Read our review by Skees here:
http://www.sitcomsonline.com/rhodaseason1dvdreview.html

Please post any questions or comments about this set.

WOW...EDITED EPISODES.....there goes the Shout factory appreciation thread....lol....I still love them and are leaders with MPI in releasing stuff other studios wouldn't touch and for that I will always support them. But our friend Shout contributor admitted that the episodes would contain flaws but they would not be edited.....I am not starting a war here, but he has made many contradictory statements regarding many sets....my suggestion would be, if he doesn't know for sure and he is representing the company, make sure the post is absolutely accurate.

Here is what Brian Ward, a sitcoms poster and Shout rep posted in February 2009 regarding the upcoming Rhoda set...it is shown here unedited and unaltered for factual information only.....

"I actually think we did very well with getting the complete episodes of Rhoda. I will forwarn you that there are some occasional tape problems, simply from the age and storage of the material, but I don't think it'll distract from your entertainment too much. We actually spent months going through masters, returning them and bringing new ones in, and have found the absolute best that Fox and a couple private collectors have to offer.

As for the bonus material, the interview with James L. Brooks especially was a dream come true for me. It was a lot of fun. He's a great guy and I think it comes off rather well in the piece.

It's a pretty good set. I'm happy with it and I think you will be, too."

Lee G · 03-19-2009, 01:43 PM

Upon reading this review, I will save my money and not buy this DVD. I too, was under the impression the episodes would be uncut with some minor video issues. The edited episodes really kill it for me, this will be exactly like Father Knows Best season one. At least Room 222 season one has all uncut episodes, I will be ordering that DVD.

In my opinion, Shout Factory is not all that great. Some of their releases are good, some are bad. With these bad releases like FKB S1 and Rhoda S1, if that is the best they can do then they should not issue it at all. I have a beef with this company anyway because of the non-release for The Bill Cosby Show season 2.

catlover79 · 03-19-2009, 01:47 PM

Edited episodes - what a bummer.

I still will check this out of the library, because I have not seen many of the episodes. I also look forward to checking out the extras.

gotsmart · 03-19-2009, 04:21 PM

What a disappointment. I was really looking forward to this release. Hopefully they will be able to include unedited episodes on future seasons (if they are released, I imagine that many people will be canceling their pre-orders.)

Benno123 · 03-19-2009, 05:03 PM

And I just hit the cancel button for my order

And I was looking forward to this release, too. I will not knowingly pay for inferior quality. Thanks for the review and letting the fans know ahead of time!

Eric Paddon · 03-19-2009, 08:26 PM

I'm more ticked off that Shout decided to invest their money on blatantly compromised material instead of saving to get out more of their abandoned titles.

JAldridge86 · 03-19-2009, 08:44 PM

Yeah...cancelling mine too. I'll be happy with my TV Land recordings, and the 1992 MTM videos.

TVFactFan · 03-19-2009, 09:05 PM

Edited Episodes + horrible quality=NO PURCHASE

Unbelievable. I just feel sorry for the people who are fans of the show who are not able to read this review and when but the DVD and get a big disapppointment

catlover79 · 03-19-2009, 09:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TJ

“My name is Rhoda Morgenstern. I was born in the Bronx, New York in December 1941.” That was how Valerie Harper began every single episode of the first season of Rhoda, the first spinoff of the popular 1970s TV series, The Mary Tyler Moore Show. And now, that very first season of Rhoda is available on DVD, for the very first time! Season One contains all 24 episodes of the 1974-1975 season of the series on a four disc DVD set, just in time for the 35th anniversary.

Rhoda Morgenstern began as a character on The Mary Tyler Moore Show, but proved to be popular enough to earn her own sitcom by 1974. The series begins as she takes a vacation back home to New York and stays with her sister, Brenda (Julie Kavner). While staying with her sister, she meets a construction worker named Joe (David Groh) and they hit it off almost immediately. Things go so well that Rhoda decides to stay in Manhattan for a while, but as she emphasizes in her opening monologue, “New York, this is your last chance!” The series ran for five seasons on CBS and Rhoda and Joe eventually married each other... and then eventually divorced each other... but the series went on anyway. The show also stars Nancy Martin as Rhoda’s overbearing mother, Ida, and Harold Gould as her more understand father, Martin.

Read our review by Skees here:
http://www.sitcomsonline.com/rhodaseason1dvdreview.html

Please post any questions or comments about this set.

Not to be picky, but shouldn't that be Nancy WALKER playing Ida??

Marvo301 · 03-19-2009, 09:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by catlover79

Not to be picky, but shouldn't that be Nancy WALKER playing Ida??

YES!!!! It should!

DallasFan · 03-19-2009, 09:24 PM

Well I am cancelling my pre-order too. What a bummer. I was looking forward to this show on DVD. I guess I will buy something else in its place.

JMFabiano524 · 03-20-2009, 06:18 PM

I'll probably end up buying it, just cause it is Rhoda and how else will I get it? (If anyone knows anyone who DOES have pristine, unedited episodes, please dish it out ASAP!) And no sales = no further releases.

As for editing, as long as the show is still funny, it's often overrated.

Doesn't someone at Shout! post here? Maybe he could give some insight as to what happened? And I wonder how much of this comes down to Fox, and if so, I am now wondering what Mary Tyler Moore ever did to them to deserve having her material treated like this? (did Fox give them lousy prints on purpose so they don't overshadow their own releases, like of TMTMS whenever THAT will be now???)

Well...is the vaunted first episode scene with Mary saved at least? (I know Rhoda's Wedding is in the original format)

I wonder if Shout can come up with replacement discs someday, like the whole CBS/Fugitive incident.

I am so down today...what once seemed like the most promising time for MTM Universe fans is crashing all around me.

TVFactFan · 03-20-2009, 06:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JMFabiano524

I'll probably end up buying it, just cause it is Rhoda and how else will I get it? (If anyone knows anyone who DOES have pristine, unedited episodes, please dish it out ASAP!) And no sales = no further releases.

As for editing, as long as the show is still funny...I guess I'll live.

Doesn't someone at Shout! post here? Maybe he could give some insight as to what happened? And I wonder how much of this comes down to Fox, and if so, what did Mary Tyler Moore do to them to have her material treated like this? (did Fox give them lousy prints on purpose so they don't overshadow their own releases, like of TMTMS whenever THAT will be now???)

Well...is the vaunted first episode scene with Mary saved at least? (I know Rhoda's Wedding is in the original format)

I wonder if Shout can come up with replacement discs someday, like the whole CBS/Fugitive incident.

I am so down today...what once seemed like the most promising time for MTM Universe fans is crashing all around me.

I don't think no one cares about a future release if the first release is THIS BAD. I mean you want to spend money on Poor Quality and Edited Eps? Why?? And I know there is no way to get great Quality eps that are UNCUT but that doesn't mean you take your hard earned money and buy CRAP

JMFabiano524 · 03-20-2009, 06:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TVandSportsGuy

I don't think no one cares about a future release if the first release is THIS BAD. I mean you want to spend money on Poor Quality and Edited Eps? Why?? And I know there is no way to get great Quality eps that are UNCUT but that doesn't mean you take your hard earned money and buy CRAP

Like I said, just cause it's Rhoda and how else will I get them?

And who's to say that if there's later seasons, they won't improve? (Shout! did rectify similar problems in the past) Unless I am right about my imaginary Fox conspiracies.

03-19-2009, 01:51 AM	#1
TJ Administrator Administrator Join Date: Feb 03, 2000 Location: Marietta, GA Posts: 7,592	Rhoda - Season One DVD Review “My name is Rhoda Morgenstern. I was born in the Bronx, New York in December 1941.” That was how Valerie Harper began every single episode of the first season of Rhoda, the first spinoff of the popular 1970s TV series, The Mary Tyler Moore Show. And now, that very first season of Rhoda is available on DVD, for the very first time! Season One contains all 24 episodes of the 1974-1975 season of the series on a four disc DVD set, just in time for the 35th anniversary. Rhoda Morgenstern began as a character on The Mary Tyler Moore Show, but proved to be popular enough to earn her own sitcom by 1974. The series begins as she takes a vacation back home to New York and stays with her sister, Brenda (Julie Kavner). While staying with her sister, she meets a construction worker named Joe (David Groh) and they hit it off almost immediately. Things go so well that Rhoda decides to stay in Manhattan for a while, but as she emphasizes in her opening monologue, “New York, this is your last chance!” The series ran for five seasons on CBS and Rhoda and Joe eventually married each other... and then eventually divorced each other... but the series went on anyway. The show also stars Nancy Walker as Rhoda’s overbearing mother, Ida, and Harold Gould as her more understand father, Martin. Read our review by Skees here: http://www.sitcomsonline.com/rhodaseason1dvdreview.html Please post any questions or comments about this set. Last edited by TJ : 03-21-2009 at 12:58 AM.

03-19-2009, 01:47 PM	#4
catlover79 Moderator Forum Legend God Bless Val Join Date: May 29, 2006 Location: Bewitched in Ohio Posts: 69,229	Edited episodes - what a bummer. I still will check this out of the library, because I have not seen many of the episodes. I also look forward to checking out the extras. __________________ "Jesus loves you and He approves this message." "I'm alive. I'm feeling good. I'm trying to live every moment as much as I can." - Valerie Harper, March 2013

03-19-2009, 04:21 PM	#5
gotsmart Forum Regular The Office, Thursdays on NBC Join Date: May 05, 2007 Location: Schrute Farms Posts: 341	What a disappointment. I was really looking forward to this release. Hopefully they will be able to include unedited episodes on future seasons (if they are released, I imagine that many people will be canceling their pre-orders.) __________________ From The Office, Pam: Time cards, he has to sign these every Friday. Purchase orders have to be approved at the end of every month. And Expense Reports, all he has to do is initial these at the end of every quarter. But once every year it all falls on the same Friday; That's today. I call it the perfect storm.

03-19-2009, 08:44 PM	#8
JAldridge86 Forum Regular Member Join Date: Sep 24, 2003 Location: Macon, GA Posts: 506	Yeah...cancelling mine too. I'll be happy with my TV Land recordings, and the 1992 MTM videos. __________________ http://www.youtube.com/user/JAldridge86

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

03-19-2009, 01:43 PM	#3
Lee G Banned!! 50's 60's & 70's TV Join Date: Jun 24, 2004 Posts: 845	Upon reading this review, I will save my money and not buy this DVD. I too, was under the impression the episodes would be uncut with some minor video issues. The edited episodes really kill it for me, this will be exactly like Father Knows Best season one. At least Room 222 season one has all uncut episodes, I will be ordering that DVD. In my opinion, Shout Factory is not all that great. Some of their releases are good, some are bad. With these bad releases like FKB S1 and Rhoda S1, if that is the best they can do then they should not issue it at all. I have a beef with this company anyway because of the non-release for The Bill Cosby Show season 2.

03-19-2009, 05:03 PM	#6
Benno123 Senior Member Jenna Fischer Rocks My World!! Join Date: Nov 01, 2005 Location: Ohio Posts: 1,026	And I just hit the cancel button for my order And I was looking forward to this release, too. I will not knowingly pay for inferior quality. Thanks for the review and letting the fans know ahead of time!

03-19-2009, 08:26 PM	#7
Eric Paddon Frequent Poster Member Join Date: Jan 22, 2006 Posts: 164	I'm more ticked off that Shout decided to invest their money on blatantly compromised material instead of saving to get out more of their abandoned titles.

03-19-2009, 09:05 PM	#9
TVFactFan Forum Legend Member Join Date: Aug 17, 2002 Posts: 89,370	Edited Episodes + horrible quality=NO PURCHASE Unbelievable. I just feel sorry for the people who are fans of the show who are not able to read this review and when but the DVD and get a big disapppointment

03-19-2009, 09:24 PM	#12
DallasFan Frequent Poster Member Join Date: Feb 13, 2009 Posts: 39	Well I am cancelling my pre-order too. What a bummer. I was looking forward to this show on DVD. I guess I will buy something else in its place.

03-20-2009, 06:18 PM	#13
JMFabiano524 Forum Regular Member Join Date: Jun 04, 2002 Posts: 450	I'll probably end up buying it, just cause it is Rhoda and how else will I get it? (If anyone knows anyone who DOES have pristine, unedited episodes, please dish it out ASAP!) And no sales = no further releases. As for editing, as long as the show is still funny, it's often overrated. Doesn't someone at Shout! post here? Maybe he could give some insight as to what happened? And I wonder how much of this comes down to Fox, and if so, I am now wondering what Mary Tyler Moore ever did to them to deserve having her material treated like this? (did Fox give them lousy prints on purpose so they don't overshadow their own releases, like of TMTMS whenever THAT will be now???) Well...is the vaunted first episode scene with Mary saved at least? (I know Rhoda's Wedding is in the original format) I wonder if Shout can come up with replacement discs someday, like the whole CBS/Fugitive incident. I am so down today...what once seemed like the most promising time for MTM Universe fans is crashing all around me.