Who thinks 'American Idol' is getting old

[MonarC]

im so sick of this show :rolleyes:

[C Doody]

All Reality Shows Need To Die.

[vienna waits]

Wrong board. I'm sick of bad auditions but everything else about American Idol is just as great as ever. I think you're just looking for something to hate on because everyone's hating on you right now.

[MonarC]

actually it's called stating my opinion. And i could care less if a few people are 'hating' on me. UmmmK:D

[consentida]

Despite the fact that I hate all the other reality shows, I like American Idol. I like watching the auditions- good and bad. I like it because of the music and hearing new voices and seeing new faces. Its interesting.

[Mijada]

I don't watch it so I really don't care. I do think that there are way too many reality shows on though.

[Czas na Zywiec]

my original statement still stand, you're nothing but an attention whore. :o this topic belongs on the reality board. you knowingly posted it here so more people could notice you. :o

[~LadyJess~]

I didn't watch a whole lot of the first American Idol, more of the second one and so far all of the third one. I think it's a good show and I'm not sick of it yet.

[vienna waits]

Originally posted by MonarC
actually it's called stating my opinion. And i could care less if a few people are 'hating' on me. UmmmK:D

then stop taking up pages in threads firing back at people.

[AnaheimPMWitch]

I dont like Reality shows so theres your answer

[Rhiannon]

Originally posted by Captain Juke "N" Jive
All Reality Shows Need To Die.

yes!!

I only watched the auditions for American Idol, but they're something I can definately live without.

[MonarC]

I hate the fact that the cancel That 70's Show to aire AI :mad:

[*Pleasant Tomorrow*]

Originally posted by Mijada
I don't watch it so I really don't care. I do think that there are way too many reality shows on though.

Yeah, same way I feel.

And, also, how many American Idols can you have? :lol:

[David]

Originally posted by consentida
Despite the fact that I hate all the other reality shows, I like American Idol. I like watching the auditions- good and bad. I like it because of the music and hearing new voices and seeing new faces. Its interesting. thats what i like too. Its a fun ride, and its a great way to find new singers. I actually think American Idol is the best way to get discovered, because you see their strengths, weaknesses, and everything about them, prior to their first album.

Also, i dont think its getting old! Its just in its 3rd season, and actually, i think there'll be a lot of them to be honest. Even when i grow out of it, i think it will still be going on. It's FOX's number 1 show

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

I love AI!! Thats where Clay came from..:D:D:D I'm not sick of it, but I've had my full dosage of bad auditions.. time for the real deal now!:cool:

[Brian]

Heck no! I think this is an awesome show that will be around for a while. The thing I like about this show is the progression. It starts with the ocapella auditions and ends with two excellent, awesome, and extremely musically talented individuals vieing for the title of American Idol, not to mention the nonstop competition in the middle. You can really tell the beginning, middle, and end and each stage is great to watch.

[DianeChambers87]

I'm so ready for this reality phase to die...

[vashti1999]

I voted "no way I love it", it's still a very entertaining show. I love the BAD auditions.

[Christopher]

Originally posted by MonarC
I hate the fact that the cancel That 70's Show to aire AI :mad:




They didn't cancel That 70's Show. It still airs on Wednesdays or Mondays, which ever day they air that pathetic excuse for a comedy.


I think the only interesting episodes of American Idol are the auditions. After those are over, it gets kind of boring.

[David]

Originally posted by Brian
Heck no! I think this is an awesome show that will be around for a while. The thing I like about this show is the progression. It starts with the ocapella auditions and ends with two excellent, awesome, and extremely musically talented individuals vieing for the title of American Idol, not to mention the nonstop competition in the middle. You can really tell the beginning, middle, and end and each stage is great to watch. Exactly. Its interesting, and it has different journeys. There is some awesome talent on the show too

[HuntingtonM15]

I'm kinda getting tired of the auditions. They aren't as funny as they were in past seasons. Too many of them just seem fake. It's getting repetitive. Hopefully I'll like the rest of the season better.

[ChristyHeadIsSexy]

I voted "no way I love it". The show is still fun to watch and I've seen all the episodes from the beginning of AI1. The show is only getting more and more popular. And has many more viewers.

[Brian]

Originally posted by HuntingtonM15
I'm kinda getting tired of the auditions. They aren't as funny as they were in past seasons. Too many of them just seem fake. It's getting repetitive. Hopefully I'll like the rest of the season better.


Hopefully in AI4, they'll cut back on the airing of the bad auditions. They went overboard on those in Houston. It is one of those cases in which too much of a good thing (or bad thing, depending on how you see it) is not good. Don't get me wrong, I like watching the bad auditions but it is bad when three-quarters of the episode are fillem with them. But at least Simon had some really funny stuff to say. I think he was funnier this season than last season.

[Brian]

Originally posted by ChristyHeadIsSexy
I voted "no way I love it". The show is still fun to watch and I've seen all the episodes from the beginning of AI1. The show is only getting more and more popular. And has many more viewers.


It is Fox's highest rated show aside from The Simpsons. But I talked to PB about the ratings and he said that Fox's other series are not doing well in the Nielsens. Without AI and The Simpsons, Fox would be screwed.

[db108108]

I watched the audition episode, but have no interest in the rest of it. It was all the same.

Simon: That was absolutely horrdeous. That's the worst thing I've ever heard in my life

Paula: I love your style, but you're really not what we're looking for.

Randy: It's a no for me.

Audtioner: (outside the room, in tears) They just made the biggest mistake ever because this face is going to be on every album cover. I could have made them alot of money. (mother hugs them)

Mom: It's okay dear, they don't know anything. You're really great....

After seeing this five times, it got old for me.

And without AI, yes, Fox would be screwed. Almost every one of their series are down this year, except Saturday. The only bright light on that network outside of AI is The OC.

[David]

Originally posted by Brian
Hopefully in AI4, they'll cut back on the airing of the bad auditions. They went overboard on those in Houston. It is one of those cases in which too much of a good thing (or bad thing, depending on how you see it) is not good. Don't get me wrong, I like watching the bad auditions but it is bad when three-quarters of the episode are fillem with them. But at least Simon had some really funny stuff to say. I think he was funnier this season than last season. Yup, they went overboard on the bad auditions. But, the great part of American Idol is in the top 12, which is yet to come. That's where we see talent. The auditions are just the start. I cant wait till then. :)

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Originally posted by Brian
It is Fox's highest rated show aside from The Simpsons. But I talked to PB about the ratings and he said that Fox's other series are not doing well in the Nielsens. Without AI and The Simpsons, Fox would be screwed. :nod: I remember reading way back when that ABC had first dibs on AI, but passed. Bet they're kicking themselves now. ohno:

[Brian]

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
:nod: I remember reading way back when that ABC had first dibs on AI, but passed. Bet they're kicking themselves now. ohno:


I didn't know that. That sucks big time for ABC, then.

[David]

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
:nod: I remember reading way back when that ABC had first dibs on AI, but passed. Bet they're kicking themselves now. ohno: aw man, that sucks for ABC! AI would've brought them back up, since they've been behind NBC and CBS the past few seasons.

[Vegas Girl]

I'm surprised the girl that called Simon gay didn't get cut. Paula really gave her a tongue lashing.

[LucyCompanyPhan]

I like american Idol. I like this season better than season 2 so far... but yeah it was annoying watching all the bad singers, they weren't much fun. I really enjoyed last nights episode. Some stuff was really funny. haha

[David]

Originally posted by Vegas Girl
I'm surprised the girl that called Simon gay didn't get cut. Paula really gave her a tongue lashing. i know!!! i didnt like her and especially her attitude

[David]

Originally posted by LucyCompanyPhan
I like american Idol. I like this season better than season 2 so far... but yeah it was annoying watching all the bad singers, they weren't much fun. I really enjoyed last nights episode. Some stuff was really funny. haha

I loved last nights episode too. I really cant wait for tonights episode!

[Brian]

Originally posted by [.AIkenCompany3.]
I loved last nights episode too. I really cant wait for tonights episode!


I have to agree with you there. I hope that big guy (not the Hawaiian guy) in the group with Jesus makes it but in one of the promos it doesn't look like that will happen.

I was stunned when I heard that Kira made it. If she remains in the running for the title, she would give AI a bad taste in its mouth.

[david&maddie4ever]

Originally posted by Vegas Girl
I'm surprised the girl that called Simon gay didn't get cut. Paula really gave her a tongue lashing.

I was surprised, too, but then my dad said they probably kept her because they hadn't tortured her enough yet. They'll cut her late in the game. What a big-mouth. You've gotta be a real jerk for Paula to freak out on you. ohno:

~Lauren

:sheep

[Dean Winchester]

all reality shows need to die

I also think Simon is unnecessarily rude to people. I think it's funny he tells people they don't deserve a recording contract because they "can't sing", when we have people like J. Lo and Britney selling millions upon millions of albums, and neither of those are exactly what you'd call a good singer.

I also think people make too big a political issue over American Idol, IT'S ENTERTAINMENT, PEOPLE!! I mean, when Tamyra Gray was voted off, I remember a lot of people making a huge political deal about "she was voted off because racist whites don't want a black idol". And you still see mud flung between both Clay and Ruben fans, which I find funny because I DON'T GIVE TWO CRAPS ABOUT EITHER!!!!