next to leave

[vienna waits]

who do you predict will be the next to get the boot? hopefully, corey! he's overdue. But, it wouldn't surprise me if Trenyce was in the bottom three as well because of her shady past.

[GrapeJelly]

Gotta see the performances to decide. I try to be fair and let them sing first lol but Corey's flubbed quite a few shows and Trenyce's closet bones made a special guest appearance so you just may be right about those two ;)

[-*Leah*-]

I feel so sorry for Trenyce. Her background is going to ruin her.Now that all of this has came out, there is NO way that she will make it to the final 3. This also came at a very bad time for her, because she was just becoming really good. She wasn't my favorite out of all the finalists, but I would have liked her to stayed longer than Cory, and Ricky and some of the others. Oh well, I guess her problems are her fault. I want Josha Gracin and Kimberly Caldwell to be in the top 5 along with Clay Aiken and Kimberly Locke, and I want Ruben to win ! Ruben all the way !! Anyways, theres my "up to date" opinion on American Idol...ENJOY!!!:D :crazy: :talk:

[David]

my bottom 3- Cory, Rickey, and either Trenyce or Josh..

my top 3-- Kimberly Caldwell, Clay, Carmen

[britt britt]

I hope Corey goes. I never thought he was a good singer.

[Sitcomwriter]

It has to be Corey.The guy is a freak.

[GrapeJelly]

Fox already announced he's been officially expelled from the competition.

[MidnightRose21498]

Originally posted by GrapeJelly
Fox already announced he's been officially expelled from the competition.

Where did you see that? I want to see it too. :-)

My brother heard that Trenyce was arrested again for driving drunk or something like that in the last couple of weeks. I don't know if that's like the rumor game.. .you know, where somebody tells someone else fact and it gets twisted down the line into something totally different. You know what I mean, right? The whole thing about her being arrested for theft got turned into drunk driving somewhere down the line. Or, both could be true. She's a good singer but AI needs to do more extensive background checks next time so they don't find out things in the middle of the season and have to kick people out of the show.

[GrapeJelly]

Originally posted by MidnightRose21498


Where did you see that? I want to see it too. :-)



It's all over the internet. Try a Google or Yahoo search. Or CNN.com. Or ETonline.com. Or Thesmokinggun.com. Or maybe even MTV.com. I'm sure it'll only take a few moments to find.

[Striel]

Corey or Carmen should be the next to go.

[-*Leah*-]

Originally posted by Striel
Corey or Carmen should be the next to go.
Agreed , and now that Corey is gone, It has to be Carmen..(sorry all Carmen fans)

[vienna waits]

My bottom three from tonight: Rickey Smith, Kimberly Caldwell, Josh Gracin. Rickey should go.

[vienna waits]

Originally posted by YearbookLoser
My bottom three from tonight: Rickey Smith, Kimberly Caldwell, Josh Gracin. Rickey should go.

I wasn't very impressed with Trenyce though either.. toss up between her and kim c.

[sara]

I think Josh might be cut.:( . It's sad because I really like Josh, but I think he was the worst performer tonight.

[ThomasE]

Originally posted by sara
I think Josh might be cut.:( . It's sad because I really like Josh, but I think he was the worst performer tonight.

Is that the gut that sung "celebrate good times"?

[vienna waits]

Originally posted by ThomasE


Is that the gut that sung "celebrate good times"?

yah

[GrapeJelly]

I think Josh and Rickey were the bottom performers tonight. I'd be sad to see either of them go, but Rickey in particular cuz he's just so sweet and always smiling...aww, I'm sad already lol :p

[Cashodeen]

I think the next to leave will be Ricky. I'm thinking the other two that are close calls will be Carmen and maybe the marine (forget his name). It was unfair that this was just not his genre, and I think he said he was ill. Hopefully people will realize that and he'll stay out of the bottom three and Kimberly just may be there instead.

[Rob1]

I think that Ricky, Carmen, and Josh will be the next three people to go.

[Rob1]

I

[David]

After watching, I have to say my bottom 3 are.....

Josh, Rickey, and Trenyce..... with the door shown to Rickey

[Cashodeen]

I know there are some Kimberly Caldwell fans here. Even if you're not a fan, feel free to respond. What did you think of Paula's comments toward Kimberly? I wasn't exactly sure what she was getting at, nor did I ever think something like that would come out of her mouth.

[David]

Um, I'm a Kim Caldwell fan, and personally I thought her performance was outstanding. The only thing I didnt like was when she went "ooo".. she has to work on that.

But, about Paula's comment. It wasnt too negative. It was just a "take this into consideration" comment. I think she meant that she needs to add in more difference in her voice ... im not too sure.

Another thing. Is a 6 1/2 outta 10 good for yall?

[Cashodeen]

Yeah, Paula's comment wasn't TOO negative (certainly doesn't compare to Simon's brutally honest tactics). I just thought it was weird how she threw in there that she was "worried" about Kimberly.

A 6 1/2 out of 10 is fair. Simon said that about Kimberly, didn't he? I really thought the reactions to Kimbery's performance would have been much better than what she got from the judges. I'm not pulling for her to take it all, but last night I thought she did well. She definitely should be around for next week and then some.

[David]

Yeah, Simon said that about Kim C... and I agree, her performance was good.. I think the arrangement, as Randy said, wasnt that great