I cant believe Kimberly Caldwell was in the bottom 3!

[David]

I absolutley absolutely absolutely CANNOT believe that Kimberly Caldwell was in the bottom 3. And another thing, I cried during this show, seeing Julia go. She seems like a really nice person, but she hadda go someday.

EVERYONE VOTE FOR KIMBERLY CALDWELL

[Cashodeen]

I actually was suprised to see that Kimberly in the bottom three. I was also very suprised to not see Corey Clark (that's his name right?) in the bottom three. I thought he was weak. He should probably be booted next Wednesday.

[Rob1]

I was suprised to see her in the bottom three as well. I think that Kimberly is one of the most talented contestents on the show. Now, I hope that nobody minds if I go slightly off topic - about Simon. I think that most of the time, he just says things to purposely upset everyone. At first, he said Kimberly was just great - but last night, he said that she deserved to be in the bottom three. Anyone else notice that?

[GrapeJelly]

I voted like crazy. I'm very surprised as well. :eek:

[David]

Originally posted by Rob1
I was suprised to see her in the bottom three as well. I think that Kimberly is one of the most talented contestents on the show. Now, I hope that nobody minds if I go slightly off topic - about Simon. I think that most of the time, he just says things to purposely upset everyone. At first, he said Kimberly was just great - but last night, he said that she deserved to be in the bottom three. Anyone else notice that?

YES! I noticed that exact same thing. I'm a big Am. Idol/Kim Caldwell fan, and I tape everything. And I noticed that Simon does that to everyone a lot, esp. Kimberly.

For example, in the top 12 performances, Simon said "Great, best so far", the next week in the top 11 performances, Simon said "Kimberly, we havent seen your potential yet". And then in the top 10 performances, he said "I wasnt impressed... until now" and then in the top 10 kickoffs, he said that she deserved to be in the bottom 3. I think he thinks Kimberly Caldwell is more looks than talent, but I think she has both.

[nice~girl~2003]

are u talkin bout that dumb ai show...kim c, she dumb and cant sang

[GrapeJelly]

Originally posted by nice~girl~2003
are u talkin bout that dumb ai show...kim c, she dumb and cant sang

Sure live up to your nick, don't you? :p First of all, your sig is ridiculously long. Secondly, someone posting sentences like "she dumb and cant sang" is hardly in a position to call other people dumb. :rolleyes:

[nice~girl~2003]

Originally posted by GrapeJelly


Sure live up to your nick, don't you? :p First of all, your sig is ridiculously long. Secondly, someone posting sentences like "she dumb and cant sang" is hardly in a position to call other people dumb. :rolleyes:

oh hesh up grap jely, and mind ur on bus, or i'll be men 2 u

[nice~girl~2003]

Okay, everyone I am really sorry. I am really not like that. I thought that this website was a hoax, so I thought that I would come and check it out, and see if everyone was real, and everyone obviously is. My vobcabulay and spelling aren't really that bad, and I am really not that mean. I like American Idol, and I am sorry if I hurt anybody's feelings with my little experiment. Can you all forgive me?:confused: :(

[GrapeJelly]

Riiiiiight :p

[sara]

I like Kimberly but I would have put in the bottom 3. I was not impressed at all by her last perfomance. I found it boring. I'm glad she wasn't cut though because I think she is talented. I was really glad that Julia is gone, I never liked her.

[ThomasE]

Was Julia the kind of chubby girl who had a makeover and wore some blue dress that Simon did not like a week and a half ago?(That was when Gladys Knight was a guest judge)

[-*Leah*-]

I was totally expecting it to be Julia and Cory as the bottom 2. I don't understand why Kimberly was there.:rolleyes:

[-*Leah*-]

Originally posted by ThomasE
Was Julia the kind of chubby girl who had a makeover and wore some blue dress that Simon did not like a week and a half ago?(That was when Gladys Knight was a guest judge)
Nope, you are thinking about Kimberly Locke I think. Julia is kind of skinny, white, and she has brown hair.:p

[David]

A little old topic...and I know this doesnt matter at ALL anymore, but ..

I found out like a month ago that there was a phone glitch on Kim C, Julia, and Clay's line.

According to some AI website, actually like 3 AI websites and forums, the first 30 mins-1 hour of each of their lines were not working, meaning that voters could not get their vote in. And even though I'm not sure if it's officially confirmed (but i think it is), but I do remember trying to vote and not getting ANY respose.

The phone glitch affected Kim C and Julia's lines the most, cuz Clay's fans brought it in as usual. Even witch the phone screw up, he was safe.

But with Kim C and Julia, in their phone glitches, Julia got the least votes. Producers were gonna redo the voting and move the results show to Thursday, or just announce it on the website, but if you doubled Julia's votes, she wouldnt've been safe anyways, so they decided to let her go. Now with Kim C, her vote was only 5% away from Rickey (now thats good considering the fact that 1 hour of votes was wasted).

The question was, "should they put her in the bottom 3?". What they were originally gonna do was put Kim, Julia, and Rickey in the bottom 3, and then Ryan would announce that one of them had a phone problem, and send that one back to safety. But the announcement of a phone problem, might've led to future "the voting is rigged" rumors. So, they decided to put Kim and Julia in the bottom 2 so they can have a last minute Julia vs. Kim match again. (gosh that is so old ppl!).

According to the thing I read, they told Kim that she had a phone problem, and that she just has to go with the flow, cuz they cant change the seating arrangement 2 hours before show time. And I can kinda tell that Kim knew, cuz when Ryan was announcing "safe or not".. it seems like when he said she was in the bottom 3, that she already KNEW, cuz she just stood up, she wasnt surprised or anything.

The article also said that Kim had problems trying to hold in her tears while she was in the"rejects circle" as the forum says. And that she hated the way the producers put her head to head with her former "rival".

There were other things said on here... like stuff about her mascara running, and how Clay also knew Julia was out, and how he felt sad for her because it was her best nite... and blah blah...

but if u r wondering how i remember all this, its cuz im a huge AI/Kim C fan... lol....