Who Do U Think Should've Won American Idol?

[isiahthomas]

I think it should've been the black girl Tamera or Tamara, however u spell her name. That girl could sing & she's definitely in my opinion a better singer than Kelly Clarkson. That red haired girl was lucky she lasted as long as she did cause she sucked. Justin sucked too with his nappy hair. Only reason why he lasted as long as he did was because of the girls, he ain't got no talent. What's the other black girl's name that was in the hospital for a few days? She could sing. I saw all of them recently on a Old Navy commercial pretending like they were playing Family Feud. Kelly & Justin wasn't with the ones who lost. Paula Abdul i see still looks so good, she's a good judge. I like Simon because he tells it like it is. Is Randy Jackson & Paula gonna join Simon next season as judges again?

[Mr. Stefani]

I've never seen an episode. Kelly Clarkson is annoying.

[fr00ti]

I think that.... I don't know. I never saw it.

[Brian Damage]

[i]Is Randy Jackson & Paula gonna join Simon next season as judges again? [/B]

Yes

[AllIWantIsYourClutch]

Kelly Clarkson annoys me

[nmnf920]

Kelly clarkson's a moment like this song sucks.

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

Kelly's voice is awesome. I also liked RJ, Nikki, and Tamyra. Its a tie between Tamyra and Kelly though. Justin just pissed me off. His tumbleweed you'd call hair needs to meet scissors STAT.

[sweetsuga]

Tamyra!!!!!!!!!! She was REALLY good!

[SBTB Geek]

Kelly deserved it.

I'm glad Side Show Bob didn't get it!

[britt britt]

Originally posted by SBTB Geek


I'm glad Side Show Bob didn't get it!

LOL!

I liked that Nikki girl the best.

[Beruche]

Originally posted by MaRtInA_GuRL
I think that.... I don't know. I never saw it.

me either. lol

[~*Hannah_Lee*~]

I liked that Tamera girl best. She could really sing. Kelly Clarkson kinda annoys me, but I dont listen to her enough to know. Thank goodness that beast of a man (or girl, or other.....who knows? I think i saw him wearing lipstick in one pic though) didnt win. He was freakishly scary looking.

[sara]

I think that Kelly was the best singer, but I thought Justin and Tamyra were both good. Justin's hair needs to go, my Mom thougth he was cute, but I never saw it. I was so glad that Nikki didn't win, she should have never made it as far as she did.

[Kristina]

eh I used to hate Kelly Clarkson, she isn't half bad I like 'A Moment Like This' and 'Before Your Love' grew on me. So yah I guess she deserved it.

[Christopher]

Originally posted by britt britt

I liked that Nikki girl the best.



I liked Nikki too. I wish she would have won.

[MidnightRose21498]

I liked Kelly, Nikki, Tamyra, and Christina. Justin was alright on a few songs but not over all. I really think Kelly deserved to win though. I think she's really good.

[isiahthomas]

Tamyra was on a episode of Boston Public 2 weeks ago. She's gonna be on 3 more episodes. She did good for her first acting gig. She played a student who was thinking about auditioning for the school play as a singer but she had stage fright. On next week's episode her boyfriend is gonna be abusive towards her cause he's jealous that this white dude in the play is all over her but it's just a damn play. I can't stand abusive boyfriends who are the jealous type.

[-*Leah*-]

Originally posted by SBTB Geek
Kelly deserved it.

I'm glad Side Show Bob didn't get it!
Thats what I am saying ! *LOL*

[isiahthomas]

Did ya'll see the commercial for Old Navy where all the old American Idol contestants from last yr were pretending like they were playing Family Feud? LOL. Morgan Fairchild was on the commercial too.

[RollerGirl]

I loved Nikki's style, looks, and personality but talentwise, though she was very good, she was not the best. I think Kelly deserved to win but the two singles they had her record were "just okay" as Simon would say :lol:

I loved the song "Timeless" that they showed on American Idol, but this cheesy movie Kelly and Justin are doing may just be career suicide though :eek: Time will tell....

[stainedbeautie]

Originally posted by MaRtInA_GuRL
I think that.... I don't know. I never saw it.


This is off topic, but I love Martina too :D. Maybe not as much as you, but, yeah it's all good, lol.