Garbage vs. No Doubt...

[Jordan]

Which of these two bands do you like better? They are both similar because both have female lead singers and everyone else are males. Personally, I love Garbage 100 times more, but that's only because I am a huge Garbage fan; they are my favorite! I love Shirley Manson! :happyface :happyface :happyface

[Czas na Zywiec]

I prefer No Doubt. I like their music better and I just like them better. :D

[Mossopp]

I think Garbage are better than No Doubt. I've been a Garbage fan since the very beginning and I love Shirley (us Scots lassies have to stick together! :D )
No Doubt are ok but they're nowhere near as good as Garbage and Gwen is nowhere near as cool as Shirley.
In fairness though it's a bit daft comparing Garbage and No Doubt cos they both have completely different styles of music.

[Mr. Shy Guy]

I like Garbage more.

[vienna waits]

No Doubt

[jamier42]

I like Garbage better.

[DarleneIllyria]

I like both bands, but I would have to choose No Doubt for this one. I loved most of the songs on their Tragic Kingdom cd, 2 songs on the Return to Saturn cd, and I've liked the two new songs they've done so far from Rock Steady. I like a few of Garbage songs too.

[Hollow]

No doubt

[ILuvJoandBlair]

I've never heard of Garbage so I'll have to go with no doubt.

[Kay Scarpetta]

Hmmmmmmm....I actually don't know. I just lovvvvvvvvvvvvvve Shirley Manson, but I just lovvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvve Gwen Stefani. But, I'd have to say No Doubt wins on this one! :)

[KerriBerri687]

definitley no doubt! :)

[consentida]

No Doubt...
I happen to like Shirley Manson tho...i love her style...
but No Doubt is better

[Jordan]

How much do I love Shirley Manson? Let me count the ways..............I LOVE her voice, I LOVE her hair, I LOVE her personality, I LOVE her lyrics, I LOVE her music, I LOVE her attitude, I LOVE her views, I LOVE her openness, but most of all.......

I just LOVE her! :happyface :happyface :happyface

[Jordan]

Originally posted by Mossopp
In fairness though it's a bit daft comparing Garbage and No Doubt cos they both have completely different styles of music.
True, they are differnt styles, but how many bands do you see with three men and a woman as their front person/vocalist? I don't know of many, but I could be incorrect in that thought.... :happyface :happyface :happyface

[ISmellFine]

No Doubt!

[JDS84]

No doubt.

[Swimfan85]

Originally posted by Blair n' Jo Rock
definitley no doubt! :)


yep ditto to that!!!!!! i am seeing them maybe!

[Divisionbabe05]

I think this is where I come in lol...NO DOUBT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Gwen totally kicks ass...they are just hella good! Garbage is aight, but NO DOUBT KICKS ASS!!!!!!!!!!!

[Jordan]

Originally posted by Divisionbabe05
NO DOUBT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!...they are just hella good!
LOL!

You know what's odd? Just as I started reading your post, I turned on the t.v. and No Doubt was on television. I don't know, it was a little odd, I thought. :happyface :happyface :happyface

[Ewan's My Man]

Originally posted by ILuvJoandBlair
I've never heard of Garbage so I'll have to go with no doubt.

Ditto

[readymade]

I prefer Garbage. They're one of my personal favorites. :)

Take care,
Tanya.

[Jordan]

Well, it's official! Garbage and No Doubt will be touring together in October! I guess there was an ultimate reason for me posting this poll last April! Here's the address of the article regarding the Garbage/No Doubt tour:

http://www.billboard.com/billboard/daily/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1599170

:happyface :happyface :happyface

[Faith]

Personally I would say neither.... I used to like No doubt, but not anymore. I used to like Garbage too..:D

[britt britt]

No Doubt.

[Jordan]

This is my 1000th post, so I thought it would be fitting to use it to just say how much I love Garbage! I love them
thiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiis much!

:guitar: :guitar: :guitar:

[letsgoreyes]

NO DOUBT!!!!!!!!! Last night i went to the concert with No Doubt and Garbage! :p

[Mr. Stefani]

I like them both actually(their music isn't exactly a far stretch from each other)..But I HATE the new No Doubt album, as do most of their old school fans. Garbages best IMO is Version 2.0, No Doubts best is Beacon Street Collection. I think ND needs to go back to their ska/punk influences. Enough of this dancehall crap.

Need I remind everyone: Gwen isn't No Doubt :o

[DarleneIllyria]

Originally posted by timmy087
I like them both actually(their music isn't exactly a far stretch from each other)..But I HATE the new No Doubt album, as do most of their old school fans. Garbages best IMO is Version 2.0, No Doubts best is Beacon Street Collection. I think ND needs to go back to their ska/punk influences. Enough of this dancehall crap.

Need I remind everyone: Gwen isn't No Doubt :o

I have the Beacon Street Collection. Total Hate is an awesome song. I hate the song "Underneath it All". That's the one they are playing on MTV now and I just hate it. It's just a boring song.

[Mr. Stefani]

I have the Beacon Street Collection. Total Hate is an awesome song

Total Hate and Snakes are my fav. songs from the record. I find it ironic that the album they wrote/produced/recorded on their own is their best. Its a shame that Eric Stefani left the band..thats what they are lacking. And if he were still in the band, Rock Steady(shall i say pop steady-hey baby, what were they smoking?) would of never happened(even he said he doesnt like it). The one song he did on ROS, "Staring Problem" is the one of the best on the cd.

Ok, enough rambbling.

[Jordan]

Originally posted by thegamebsc
Last night i went to the concert with No Doubt and Garbage! :p You are so lucky that you got to see Garbage -- you have absolutely no idea how jealous I am of you at this very moment! :happyface

[MonarC]

No DOUBT in my mind that No Doubt is the best!!!
http://imagecache2.allposters.com/images/140/002_6229.jpg

[¤Graced¤]

I really like No doubt and own 2 of their cds but I say Garbage is better in my opinion. I d/led their cd "Version 2.0" and it rocks!:guitar:

[*Mogwai*]

I like 'em both but I've been listening to No Doubt way longer. So I'll go with them..

[Josh9125]

No DOUBT!!!!

[felicitylen]

I'm a No Doubt fan all the way!

http://home.swipnet.se/~w-36637/nodoubt.jpg

[Unwanted Angel]

Garbage is pretty cool, i listen to them sometimes, But i like No Doubt better.

[dandelion wine]

No Doubt

[Lady T]

I love Garbage

[°Bubbly Blonde°]

No Doubt

[Mr. Stefani]

Garbage suck ass.

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

No Doubt has some good songs.

[Sterling Holobyte]

There's No Doubt , I like Garbage better!:D
Seriously though, Garbage is one of the few bands fronted by a woman, whose music I can actually get into. Because most bands with women lead singers do nothing for me. And I'm not talking sexually.;)

[Brad Russ]

I like Garbage much more. Everytime I hear the song Special played on the radio, I turn it up full blast. I also like the fact that Shirley Manson sounds so much like Chrissy Hynde from The Pretenders, who I also love! Everytime I hear a new Garbage song on the radio, I always think it's Chrissy Hynde. I have a feeling that Chrissy was a huge influence on Shirley growing up.

I do like alot of No Doubts older stuff like Spider Webs, and Don't Speak, but there newer stuff is way too mainstream, and trendy for my taste.

[pandora_spocks]

I like and listen to both, but I listen to Garbage more so I chose Garbage.

[Hollow]

no doubt. i havent heard garbage.

[The Modfather]

Originally posted by ~°Sarah°~
no doubt. i havent heard garbage.

Ditto

[Jordan]

Originally posted by mdntrider7
I have a feeling that Chrissy was a huge influence on Shirley growing up.

You are exactly right -- Chrissy was perhaps Shirley's biggest musical influence. She has spoken of the time she was so excited to meet her, and felt like she made a complete ass of herself. And in the beautifulgarbage album, Shirley thanks Chrissy for being such an influence. :happyface

[Rhiannon]

No Doubt

[Krisalicious]

I like Garbage, but I've heard more No Doubt songs, so No Doubt.

[Brad Russ]

Originally posted by Jordan
You are exactly right -- Chrissy was perhaps Shirley's biggest musical influence. She has spoken of the time she was so excited to meet her, and felt like she made a complete ass of herself. And in the beautifulgarbage album, Shirley thanks Chrissy for being such an influence. :happyface

That definitely doesn't surprise me. The very first time I heard a Garbage song, I noticed the similarities between Shirley and Chrissy both lyrically, as well as musically.

Hopefully one day Chrissy will make a guest appearance on a Garbage album. That would be cool!

[Jordan]

Originally posted by mdntrider7
Hopefully one day Chrissy will make a guest appearance on a Garbage album. That would be cool!

That would be great! Although I highly doubt that will happen this time around. Garbage are almost finished recording their as-of-yet-to-be-titled fourth album, and anticipate a February, 2004 release date. Can't wait!

[Dean Winchester]

I personally like No Doubt better, but Garbage is awesome too

[Mr. Stefani]

I still stand by this: Garbage suck ass.

Shirley is a poor mans Gwen.

[Dean Winchester]

Originally posted by Nirvana
I still stand by this: Garbage suck ass.

Shirley is a poor mans Gwen.

I'd say she's more a poor man's Deborah Harry or Chrissie Hynde. I see comparisons with those 2 (especially vocally) a lot more than with Gwen

[Mr. Stefani]

Originally posted by BuffySlayer79
I'd say she's more a poor man's Deborah Harry or Chrissie Hynde. I see comparisons with those 2 (especially vocally) a lot more than with Gwen

No, Gwen is a poor mans Debby. Well, was.

wait i got it, Shirley is a poor mans Brody.

[AllIWantIsYourClutch]

No Doubt. Yeah.

[Dean Winchester]

Originally posted by Nirvana
No, Gwen is a poor mans Debby. Well, was.

it's mostly the voice that really makes me do the comparison with Deborah Harry. In some of the songs, you think you are listening to recent Blondie

[David]

No Doubt for me :)

[~*Hannah_Lee*~]

I like them both, but I voted No Doubt.

[Raven-Symone]

I like No Doubt more then Garbage.

[SBTB Geek]

Version 2.0 was a GREAT album, "Push It," "I Think I'm Paranoid," "Special," are all classics. But after that album everything went downhill. Yet, No Doubt keeps giving us great music non-stop.