Which version of J.J. did you prefer?

[GeeBee]

Old J.J vs. new J.J.

[gilligan fanatic]

I thought he was funnier before he grew his mustache

[JeffRuss1972]

Definitely the early J.J.
;)

[bansogirl]

THE OLDER JJ was A LOT funnier!

[craftman]

I liked the older JJ better. But I still liked when he said, "Well , you know, what can I say." when he first started doing it. Then it wasn't as funny when Michael started doing it.